Roleplaying
Gentleman,
I'm a little puzzled by some of posts in the Prologue. I really liked all of the character entrances, but was a little disappointed by the lack of follow-up with person-to-person roleplaying. I know this is RPoL method is still new to most of us, so I thought I'd offer some advice.
With the exception of the Silas/Travis exchanges (which I enjoyed reading), most of the posts have been people talking "past" each other, rather than "to" each other--or comments that are general and apply to everyone, even though most of you haven't even been introduced. I'm reading this as an "observer" and it seems odd to me. A couple of characters introduced themselves and no one even said "howdy, pleased to meet you" or "where do you hail from" or "nice horse" or "what did you say your name was?" or extend a handshake or whatever. Now, I know not everyone is online every day, but there have been follow-up posts from players after these introductions that didn't include any response to someone's self-introduction.
See what I mean? Imagine yourself meeting new people for the first time at a party or other social event and not even extending a handshake and saying "nice to meet you." The idea of getting some food was good--so let's pick up by moving the group to an outdoor table and bench and starting some conversation. Your characters don't know each other and you're about to travel together, so learning a little bit about each other seems natural. I don't mean provide a laundry list of skills and history, I mean do some roleplaying and ask questions of each other and provide some answers of interest to your new companions.
These aren't really criticisms, I'm just trying to help get things moving. Again, I enjoyed the entrances, but it seems like people are struggling with the next steps . . .