Re: New Scifi Universe
In wondering what kinds of things really can only happen in scifi, I found some things
1) Artificial Life - aka sentient robots. Characters like Data in Star Trek, who are machines, but looking for meaning and emotion. Chris objected that Warforged in D&D fit this mold, but I argue it is scifi first and Warforged were basically Keith Baker's way of putting "robots" into D&D. Even now, I look at Warforged and only see scifi being forced in fantasy. Sure it's possible in fantasy, but it feels more scifi to me regardless. And what is scifi? Replacing magic with technology and getting the same effects. What is fantasy? Replacing technology with magic and getting the same effects. Some things, however, simply feel more scifi while others feel more fantasy. Sorry, but robots, sentient or otherwise, are simply WAY more scifi for me than fantasy.
2) Artificial Births - Artificial insemination, test tube babies, and surrogate mothers; If these things have been done in fantasy, I can't recall. Would definitely be something to bring up a Sneetches scenario.
3) Artificial Reality - Living inside a waking dream has been done in fantasy and even modern-day settings. Virtual reality for its own sake and as an entertainment venue, however, has mostly been scifi (such as .hack//Sign). Being addicted to the fake seems to be a theme used more than a few times in scifi.
4) Space Travel - And once again, D&D has done this and who-knows what other fantasy stories may have done "space ships in fantasy", but let's face it... whether you slap fantasy on the title or not, seeing a vehicle move around among the stars immediately invokes "scifi" in our minds, right? So what's the major thing about space travel that could cause story that couldn't happen with any other travel? The fact most scifi nerds agree on warp being the tech that permits space travel and, therefor, you could wind up in serious danger from such things. Babylon 5 made extensive use of this. Cowboy Beebop used it and added a spiritual element via the Feng shui.
(More to come later)