Gwen Meredith Howard:
Hmm... My prefered Series-es -- understandably, a lot of these won't work so well :)
Slayers (too D&D to follow this)
Claymore (^^)
Fate\Stay Night (^^)
Full Metal Alchemist
Code Geass
Death Note
Nanoha (Any one of them :) )
EARLY Bleach (Before ~ Episode 60)
Kannazuki no Miko
Strawberry Panic
I was also very satisfied with the Tales of the Abyss anime they put out.
I will state I'm not particularly a fan of Naruto.
I love Slayers. Saw it ages ago and loved it. The movie was good too.
Never seen Claymore but heard of it
Never seen Fate\Stay Night but it was by the guy who made Odin Sphere so that'd be great. LOVED Odin Sphere.
Never seen Code Geass
Death Note is friggen awesome (if slightly gay)
Never actually watched an episode of Nanoha but I hosted a game with a player who was a huge fan of it. Posted links to some parts of it. here's what I rebutted with:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6epvDqAslY
Never seen Bleach but EVERYONE talks about it.
Never seen or heard of Kannazuki no Miko
Never seen or heard of Strawberry Panic
My absolute favourite anime is One Piece. I breathe that thing.