Shayliss is, if anything, even more of a troubleseeker than her sister,
something that a DC 20 Gather Information or Knowledge (local)
check can warn a PC about.
Any refusal to accompany Shayliss back
to the store must be handled delicately; without a successful Bluff
check or a DC 20 Diplomacy check, her infatuation with the PC
quickly turns into bitter hate, and she could become a recurring foil
as she spreads slanderous rumors about the PC and his friends.

Shayliss reveals her true intentions as soon as she has her chosen
PC alone in the basement of her father’s store; her bodice comes off
and she slides herself into an embrace as she tries to guide the PC
over to a convenient cot someone’s set up in the back of the room.

Whatever develops from this awkward interlude, Shayliss’
father Ven Vinder (LN male human commoner 7) is destined to
head down into the basement not long after Shayliss makes her
move. Allow both Shayliss and the PC a DC 15 Listen check to
hear her father coming down the stairs at the far end of the basement. If neither notices his approach, they certainly will when he
finds them, roars in rage, and threatens the PC with his large and
meaty fists.

If the PC flees, Ven won’t follow, but neither will he allow the
PC or his friends to shop in his store any more. Being a well-liked
man in town, Ven’s displeasure with the PCs incurs a –2 penalty on
all Diplomacy and Gather Information checks made in town until
the PCs find some way to make things right with him.

A PC who tries to talk his way out of the situation can do so
with a successful Bluff check or a DC 20 Diplomacy check; success with a roll 10 higher than the required DC indicates that the
character has not only extricated himself, but has done so in a
way that leaves no hard feelings with Shayliss, who might try to
seduce the PC again at a later date.

This encounter is not meant to be physically ruinous to the
PCs, but it can certainly head that way—Ven might be a commoner, but he knows his way around a fistfight. If the PC retaliates with lethal force, Ven tries to flee with his daughter to call
the sheriff, at which point the PC’s reputation in town immediately falls under scrutiny. If either Ven or Shayliss are killed, the
PC faces a murder charge, spends 1d3 days in jail, and is then sent
to Magnimar for trial.

Ad Hoc Experience Award: If the PCs manage to navigate this
delicate encounter without hurting anyone and without disrupting
Vinder’s family, award them a CR 2 experience award