D&D or Dark Heresy
In reply to Theridan (msg # 1):
What about merging the two? Using D&D to play in the WarHammer universe?
I haven't picked up the DH handbook in a while, it's currently collecting dust on my bookshelf. But I'll forever hold an interest in D&D (Pathfinder would be preferred, I just like the multitude of class options). Although playing a DH game would be fun to try again.
The one thing I hated about DH was that there was limited character interaction, the game was mostly based around combat. Not that combat is bad, but bring some political intrigues or just use skills that are not labeled Melee and Ballistic. If I make a psycher or an astrogater I want to use my knowledge skills to solve a mystery. If I make a cleric, let me use my faith to try and turn heretics into true believers (they'll burn in hell if they don't choose my side, but I at least want to be given the chance to preach).
As far as setting goes, by merging DH with D&D/PF, the universe is your oyster. Dungeon crawls are still possible, but now there's some sci-fi element to them. Even traversing the skies in a flying machine would be possible, adding wonder and bewilderment to an otherwise fantasy-based environment. I could see the Chalice of the Blood Angels becoming a sought after artifact if D&D was the Apocalyptic world after events in DH. Or the Tau rising up from the depths of a disturbed holy site, after a 1000 year hibernation, to suddenly take control of everything because of their vastly superior tech. The Emperor could suddenly disappear, only to find out that Ahriman, the sorcerer of the Thousand Sons, traveled through a time portal to destroy the rise of Man. Or would be great to play in the time of the Horace Heresy, seeing if we could somehow stop the event from ever occurring. Maybe our trope of D&D characters stumbles upon some device of unknown origins only to have to battle a Tyranid brood. The possibilities are endless.
Many players might not be familiar with DH, but that doesn't mean you can't utilize that universe to run a game based on D&D/PF rules.
You've definitely got my vote!