Re: Chapter 6.1: Storm's a-comin' ((Deadwood))
In reply to Art C. Wiley (msg # 208):
"You speak as if the physical world is something mere sir! There are globes in the heavens, the contents of which are unknown! Who knows what awaits us out there. And there are worlds within the smallest things! The mere spark of electricity poses questions with no answers as of yet! And there may well be things which exist beyond physical boundaries, but these are perfectly rational. For instance, Plato believed the numbers were abstract objects which reside outside of our terrestrial domain, and while it cannot be proven, it is at least plausible. However considering that we don't even know all the mysteries a thing so ordinary as water contains, why speculate into such ventures where there is no empiricism?
"And I beg your pardon but your logic does not hold sir. If the man who invented steel lamented oh woe is me, someone may use this to forge an implement of destruction so I should cast it aside, we'd have forsaken the steam engine, the plowshare, the surgeon's scalpel... such is a world of cruel barbarism indeed.
"Indeed if the criteria for whether something is worthy to know is if it can be misused, then a nihilist would feel quite justified purging this earth of all life, human or otherwise! Does one slay a helpless infant prince, for he may become a cruel despot someday? Potential is one thing, but it is far from the only thing!
"And again sir, if the virtuous forsake the power discovery brings, then only the wicked shall prosper! It is the same with wealth, which is often considered to be evil, yet wealth prevents such dire sufferings! Do you know why the Good Samaritan was heralded for his kindness? It is because he had the money with which to effect his will! How did Jon Snow found the sanitary movement and save countless millions death and misery? It is because he had the knowledge of the scientific method to discover the way! Why must we judge everything by its worst possible use, especially in a species where the worst possible use is the least employed?
"Furthermore sir, I know not what quarrel you have with me or the new science, but I assure you I was not born a mechanic nor was a periodic table embedded in my instincts. All of the things I know I learned from practice, references written by others and instruction. Anyone can reproduce them, in theory at least."
If nothing else, Belle could talk. It was probably a good thing she wasn't a lecturer.