Re: OOC Lounge, Bar & Grill
For myself, I see the "RTJ request page" as one of the most critical deciders for whether I'll bother applying for game or not.
As a rule, the more information a GM asks for, the narrower the quality of players will (successfully) apply. I've found that games that ask for very little information up front are the ones, on the whole, that don't last; players tend toward the more casual end of the spectrum, don't invest as much of themselves in the character and as a result, are more willing to drop a game as soon as even one player starts holding things up.
This isn't to say this is always the case; it's just my experience on RPoL over the years I've been here.
The flipside of this, I've found, is that it's the GM's of games that ask for more detailed RTJ's that are often the primary cause of game-failure! After putting all the effort into creating their game and filtering players for those they consider "worthy" of their epic tale, all too often it turns out that the guys they have on board aren't what he was expecting or wanted; they're running rough-shod over his carefully planned encounters, killing the wrong NPC's and generally going off the rails as Players always do in every game, ever.
Now, this is something that every good DM knows that players do; it's just the way a game goes. When you're playing around a table with your mates, you just lump it and adjust and carry on and the story might not go exactly the way you want it to, but everyone's having fun, so it's all good. Online, however, the GM has the option of just pulling up sticks, scrapping the whole thing and starting fresh; he doesn't know his players, there's no backlash coming and the only negative consequence is that he'll have to re-write and start over. If starting over with new players is the price of the story going the way you want it, then that's a small price to a certain set of mind.
That's just my armchair psychology on the subject, anyway.
Also, I like writing character backgrounds. Often more than I like actually playing those characters!