Two Truths and a Lie
Since you guys are all 2nd level, the campaign is going to assume you all are an established adventuring party. To help create ties, we're going to play two truths and a lie. If you're not familiar, it's as the name implies. Each character will create two truths and one lie about another character. For simplicity's sake, do this for the person below you according to The Cast (obviously, Vargo will do this about Barry).
To help with things, I've decided to create a bit of backstory for you guys to expand upon.
Having decided to set off on a life of adventure, you eventually migrate to Daggerford. While Daggorford is not in and of itself a town of great renown, it's position along the Trade Way ensures its name is known. As such, it does have its fair share of troubles that it is more than willing to let budding adventurers handle.
One such trouble has recently popped up along the Trade Way outside the Misty Forest. Reports of goblin bandits and raiders have come in and the town's council has posted they are requesting help.
Having come upon the notice around the same time, the five of you band together to take care of the problem. After some fierce encounters and skilled tracking, you locate the goblin camp being led by a bugbear. You all dispatch the creatures and return with proof of your conquest. The council hails you all as heroes and thanks you for your service.
Everyone can also have an extra 50gp.