Re: OOC: The First Chapter - August 2016
In effort to keep things as organic as possible, I'm not going to offer advice beyond the suggestion that you make assumptions at your own peril. That doesn't mean your right or wrong, just that right can be wrong in this dungeon, and vice versa.
Furthermore, you're playing very low level, inexperienced characters who are just getting around to finding their way in the world. As such, they're not going to make the intuitive leaps you guys, as experienced players, would make. Be careful of metagaming, because in certain parts of this adventure, it might turn out really bad for the party.
I love playing low level characters b/c they're so ignorant, and their high mortality rate makes things interesting. Have fun with your characters, work hard to keep them alive (which, to all of your credit, you have done thus far), and take what comes. And don't make assumptions!!!
(kind of like Gandalf telling Bilbo and Co. "Don't stray from the path!" before riding away from the edge of Mirkwood!)
That's all I got. Good luck.