Re: OOC Discussion Thread
Yeah, that was always an option, but Knacks were meant as minor tweaks, akin to Pathfinder's "Traits". Edges, on the other hand, are supposed to be more like Feats.
Both were intended as things that you couldn't normally do with just skills.
I suppose there was always the option of expanding skills by Ranks, so that, say, Marskmanship Rank 2 gives you Far Shot, Rank 3 gives you Shot On the Run, etc. Or whatever. It would take the same amount of detail, just organized differently.
Of course, that almost gets back to the limitations of Levels by Class. You have to adventure so long to get that 12th level Really Cool Ability that it gets frustrating trying to attain that. The same would be true with skill Ranks. If the highest Rank in a skill that you can achieve is 12, what is the benefit you get then? And it would take soooooo long to reach that...
And, of course, once you attain it, what's the point of adventuring any more? There's nothing else to be gained.