Re: Duel #227: Latro vs. Josep
Tell me where it says i can't pinpoint an inanimate object in the same ways i can pinpoint a creature and i'll drop it.
If an inanimate wall that i've face planted on and isn't moving anywhere gets to benefit from 50% concealment just because its invisible and that's what the rules say, then surly i can perceive how tall an invisible wall is because that is what the rules allow me to do with a perception check.
I can shout at it and see how the sound reflects back. I can look at my wall of bones and see how the skeletal arms are reaching and banging their arms agains the Force wall. It can reach as high as +2 so if their arms are flat against an invisible wall there then I know at the very least it goes to +2. Heck, maybe I can smell the raw magic. Who's to say Force effects doesn't give off a scent of some kind.
The rules don't make sense sometimes. It makes no sense to me that I have a 50% chance to miss an invisible wall that completely block all forms of movement across it's surface but thats what the rules say so thats what we do.
Likewise it doesn't really make since that someone can just roll perception and figure out how tall an invisible wall is but the numbers are there. I've laid out the math. The wall has a lower base stealth check than Latro has a base perception DC, not accounting for distance. the distance is the only thing I can't know because it's something that is hidden from me.
If you really want me to declare it, Perception has always been a free action at the start of a turn and that is what i'm using.
Here's the math again, just so we're on the same page.
The wall has +40 to stealth because it is both invisible and non moving.
Because it cannot actively make stealth checks, by arena rules, its stealth check is assumed to be -10 + stealth mod + modifiers
Inanimate objects have 0 Dexterity, giving them a -5 dex modifier.
this gives the wall a stealth check of 25.
Latro's Perception DC is 36.
The wall fails to beat this.
Assuming the wall gets no size bonuses or penalties to stealth, Latro can perceive and pinpoint any space the wall takes up a maximum of 110 feet way.
This is no longer a question of if Latro can do this or not.
This is the math the rules as they are written have given us regardless of if they make sense.
Now, i will ask again.
How high does Latro estimate this wall to be?
To what space can Latro perceive this wall rising to?