While Chris' hatred of size shift utterly smashes my hopes and dreams of creating a forum based on the events of what happened between Season 2 and the Transformers Movie, I guess we'll just have to move on to making our own original series that has a strong G1 influence.
The following characters from G1 size shifted:
Blaster, Fortress Maximus, Megatron, Perceptor, Skyfire, Spectro (Reflector), Soundwave, Spyglass (Reflector), Viewfinder (Reflector), Warpath, Zarak (Scorponok's head)
However, after watching Headmasters, I'm thinking Blaster and Soundwave would be just fine keeping their alt modes. There was a scene where the autobots were throwing a party and Chromedome asked Blaster for some karaoke music. Blaster transformed into cassette player mode... but remained the same size as his robot mode suggested.
Similarly, Perceptor supposedly transforms into a microscope. But I don't remember him size shifting whenever he transformed, interestingly enough.
Along those lines, I think Megatron can change into a flying gun just like Shockwave or Sixshot could. Though I'm seriously considering a more Cybertronian style gun like with the two gun decepticons I just used as examples.
So here are the proposed cannon changes:
Blaster:
No change. He is the autobot communications officer and changes into a large sound/comm system.
Fortress Maximus:
No change. Just doen't magically get bigger than he should be (Like the cartoons) or smaller than he should be (Like the comics). His head is the size of an average sized Transformer in the fetal position. So his head is about as tall as Spectro, Spyglass and Viewfinder (AKA Reflector).
Megatron:
I think this is the one who should be changed to a more Cybertronian mode. Not caring whether he is disguised or not, Megatron would forgo the ability to have an Earth mode. Tank, Starship or flying gun, I haven't made up my mind.
Perceptor:
No change from the cartoon at all. Perceptor changes into a microscope that can see things on the smallest scale known to Cybertronians (Which I'm saying is smaller than humans would have discovered).
Skyfire:
I'm thinking a number of things for him. Either he transforms in such a fashion as to leave a large empty space inside (Indicating he expands like a backpack tent would) or he's even larger in robot mode than in the cartoons, or both. OR we could say he can't transport autobots at all. I'm more inclined to go with THAT idea. I think sentient transports for transformers should be giants. And I don't want Skyfire to be a giant. A large autobot who has officer status like the comics have been indicating, sure, but not a giant.
Soundwave:
Same as Blaster. Though I'm pondering a more decepticon approach to his alt mode. Or maybe a more super-computer alt mode. Or go TF:Cybertron and make him a spaceship.
Warpath:
He's not a minibot anymore. Best I can come up with. The only alternative is that he's a minibot who has a tank-like mode, but is still nowhere near the size of a real tank.
Zarak (Scorponok's head):
In order for Scorponok to be large enough to equal Fortress Maximus one idea I had was that Zarak doesn't transform at all, but rather just controls his transforming base from inside Scorponok's head. Another idea is that Scorponok is like Fort Max and has a head that transforms into an actual transformer. Finally, and I have a light preference for this, we could just have Scorponok be a particularly large transformer, about 2 heads taller than even Grimlock, but not a giant. The only problem with this, of course, is the void the decepticons would have of not having a Fort Max equivilent.
This brought up an interesting thought when I chatted with Chris last night about this topic. What about Prime's mysterious trailer? Which I think is an easy fix. A) I wanted to see his portable base to have more action in the series anyway. B) Nothing says Prime can't drag his trailer around from HQ to destination and back. C) If you had a portable base that had a repair bot, a spy bot, a mini supercomputer and missile launchers, wouldn't you use it in just about every mission? And finally... D) Some trucks travel without trailers... Prime could, on occasions where the portable base isn't necessary, simply be trailerless.
The other thought brought up was "Um... what about minibots? Every one of them that is a car technically would have to size shift because of their size in robot mode." Too small to be cars, too large to be other things. I hate to admit it, but this makes Skeeter from Go-Bots look good because he didn't size shift. He changed into a scooter. One thought I had was "Oh well, so much for minibots." Another thought I had was "Hmm... maybe they change into Cybertronian alt modes." and finally, "Maybe they turn into particularly small cars like a mini cooper or some such."
On a final note: Gestalts. In the cartoons, Superion and the Aerialbots were the same sizes as Menasor and the Stunticons even though airplanes and jets are supposed to be much bigger than cars. Let's not forget the Constructicons who are construction vehicles, which should make them considerably large in robot mode. Yet they were on the small side of things in the cartoon when they were in robot mode.
Lastly, and most certainly not least, this means flight is going to have to be regulated since a jet is going to have a clear advantage over most transformers due to not only the ability to fly, but ALSO the fact they would be HUGE by comparison. Without size shift, jet TFs suddenly become as big as Grimlock. So if you want flight for your TF, it will have to be robot mode and decepticon only. Which reminds me....
Decepticons have:
-Flight
-Space Bridges
Autobots have:
-Teletran 1
-Human resources and intel
One final thought: Gestalts are awesome and fun and all... but should they even exist? A question Chris and I always ask is "Why don't they just merge into giants first thing?" It's the Voltron problem. The concept of a gestalt is neato, but what is the advantage of having the seperate parts as apposed to the whole giant on the battlefield?
I should say it now... I would love to have gestalts (and minibots) in the game. I also plan to entirely re-work the cannon chars, their stats and everything since it's clear this is going to be OUR universe, not HASBRO's. ;)
And just for giggles, here's a doodle I threw together while eating pizza with Chris at our fave restaraunt "Frank's Pizza":
http://www.geocities.com/timfe...rchetypes_sketch.jpg
You'll find both his and my handwriting on it. ;)
This message was last edited by the GM at 11:54, Fri 04 July 2008.