Re: Coppernight Hold (Emerald and Flarewing)
Emerald says, "Perhaps... but he surrendered when Checkin asked it of him. If word got out we slaughtered enemies who surrendered, our reputation would prevent future surrender. Worse, word would get out we can't be trusted since Checkin's offer of surrender suggests survival. I'm in favor of tying him up and at the very least, getting info on the rest of the hold so we know what we're dealing with. If his information endangers us some way, we kill him. If not, he goes back to the village with us and has a chance to do life community service; making himself useful to good rather than a waste." She eyes the kobold, "But alive."
Emerald looks at Flarewing. "Don't get me wrong, Flarewing. You are right that we would be justified in killing him. But reputation is more valuable than a dragon's horde. And sparing those who surrender to us would be a step in the right direction for earning the reputation we will need in the future."
She then looks at Cherub. "Thanks for tying him up, dear."
Then looks at the others. "Can we all agree to keeping him alive until we're done here to see if his information was valuable?"