Re: Another wretched hive of scum and villainy - new OOC
Episode Three ended, in terms of pacing, intensity, and story engagement, where Episode One SHOULD have started. I was discussing the prequels, and other Lucas projects, with a friend of mine a few months ago and came to the startling insight that Lucas is a fantastic collaborator...but on his own, he's actually not that good. I've never seen THX-1138, so I can't speak for that, but American Graffiti is probably the only film he wrote, directed, and produced that wasn't a flop. All the Star Wars films from the original trilogy either got reworked by writers, or had someone else directing, or someone else producing. The Indiana Jones movies were collaborations.
Howard the Duck? Lucas. Red Tails? Lucas. What else has he done that's even been noteworthy? It was kind of a shocking realization, because I'd considered him a 'favorite storyteller' since I was a kid...and realizing that he's actually not much of a storyteller (but is fantastic at helping someone else tell an incredible story) kind of shifted my world perception....) You look at his filmography, and there are a LOT more misses than hits...and they're pretty big misses. And the older he gets, the further apart the hits become.