Re: OOC
For purposes of Byron's campaign "Broken Sword". In recent events, Mittens once again disturbed game to where Byron's brain just completely shut down. And this is Mittens TONED DOWN. Meanwhile, JD is going to leave the group around end of November. So out of consideration for "everyone should be having fun, including GM", as well as "we need replacement wizard", Chris offered to replace Mittens with a different character, possibly a wizard.
Possible alts Chris mentioned were Raymond, Lucky, Puck, Gale, Joey, and Jake.
Function of new alt: Replace cleric (Mittens) and/or wizard (JD).
Thoughts: We always seem to either kick so much butt healing is an afterthought, or have more than enough healing between having a cleric, a druid and a paladin. And even then, Tam has a healing staff and now found out the broken sword heals as well. So healing isn't an issue. Wizards are good for versatility, but since druids are good for that too, we might not even NEED a wizard replacement. So between plenty of healing and versatility, neither cleric nor wizard is vital. Now all that's left to worry about is: What would be most fun? So I'm going down each option, their ups, their downs, etc.
Gale:
Upside - Replaces JD's wizard and would add an interesting dimension to the group's dynamic since not only is her school specialty "illusion", so is her personality specialty. She's also very level-headed, which would cause zero friction with Byron.
Downside - Replacing a girl with another girl *might* make Byron eye-roll. But lately he's been kind of "whatever" about our alternate gender playing. The fact she is the only girl on this list of possible characters, though, is promising. Still, when JD leaves, that's one less guy in the group. Not a big deal for me, but David, who seems to be less and less into gaming, having even skipped last session entirely, would be the only guy left except Byron's NPC "Cho".
Jake:
Upside - Jake would probably be something fantastically different from everyone else since he's more into the mechanics of magic. He could be wizard, or he could be some manner of artificing prestige class. That said, probably would have to check with Byron before even bothering with building him anyway. Byron might not allow "artificers" in his world. Another upside is that his "science" mentality could have some interesting clashes with Tam's "nature" mentality. Would be humorous, for example, if Jake develops a crush on her only to constantly rub her love of nature the wrong way.
Downside - See above. Could prove hard to even find a class that suits him (though playing psion could prove fun). Having Robbie or Rover is possible NPC would fall into the category of Byron refusing to let you control your own NPC.
Joey:
Upside - He's a stern lawful good character. While David is playing such a character, the fact David is playing less and likely to leave for good (see above) makes Joey ideal for replacing Mittens AND Matthias as a tank.
Downside - Liz plays Chaotic Selfish. If her character doesn't change heart soon, I recommend not playing Joey. Tam has expressed patience with Xia, but even as a neutral good character, Tam has felt rather let down and disappointed with Xia on a number of occasions. I can see disaster from this. However, I also sense Xia is coming into her own here soon... but we'll see.
Lucky:
Upside - Barely have to put forth any effort. Just take Mittens' character sheet, and make minor adjustments since Lucky is normally a cleric.
Downside - If Chris wants to really try something new, it would make sense to try a new class. Granted, since healing was more of a "Oh and I can do that too" for Mittens, rather than Lucky's more "I can heal you?! Sweet!" attitude, it would change how cleric FEELS, but still. If Chris wants "new and different", Lucky's personality alone won't do it. And his being a cat will start to make the group wonder why people keep being cursed to become cats.
Puck:
Upside - The amusement of playing a pixie in the FIRST place is cool enough. But Puck is a pixie with immense confidence. And as a pedal, he would probably do some humorous things while meaning well and being honestly serious. Plus since you mentioned possibly a sorcerer build for him, could double as replacing JD's wizard. Personally, I see Puck's personality as something fun to have along, but...
Downside - Serious though the character may think himself to be, his actions will wind up silly and I can still see an eye roll from Byron. He's no Mittens, but his mere existence may make Bryon's brain break frequently. Then again, maybe not.
Raymond:
Upside - Sorcerer who has a paladin mentality would be fun. Zapping things with lightning primarily would be fun. And if you went "Titan Weapon" style, multiclassing him into barbarian would be fun and cool at the same time.
Downside - Race. What race is he? If cat, see Lucky's downside. If not, then... what is he?
Summary: It "feels" to me like Chris is leaning towards playing Puck and I have a leaning towards all of them. All for different reasons. As a reminder, since the worry is not "who will I replace" but rather "what will be the most fun", I'd say look at classes first, see what class interests you, and then decide on a character based on that.