Re: Chapter 6.1: Storm's a-comin' ((Deadwood))
"My good man, ethics is the foremost concern of everyone even when they pay it no mind, which we often do out of necessity for we could not possibly consider the full ramifications of any decision or we'd never decide at all. No action we take lacks some element of choice. But I digress.
"You contradict yourself my good sir. For the sake of not having a circular discussion, let us cede the ground and suppose that some intangible objects, and even beings, do exist. If they are in fact spirits, the only way to fathom their existence would be to perceive it as a mental construct, yes? For if it is not a thing of this world, our senses and empirical tests would be useless, correct? In that case fancy is our only resort.
"As for whether all my thoughts are my own, well sir, I submit to you if I don't know that, then no one does, and it makes no difference since I cannot tell either way. As for how I know? In a Cartesian sense, I cannot know absolutely due to solipsism, however I read comprehensively to the extent I am able, and every author of the human condition seems to betray a common experience across different histories and cultures. It is proof enough for me that my internal though processes are not unique.
"Now your hypothetical question... that is interesting, however it lacks a key component. I wouldn't do such a thing without an incentive, and that incentive would be informative as to whether it would be good or evil. So to answer, I would have to know why I or some hypothetical person would seek to create such a thing.
"However, a larger point to consider is that the knowledge of how to build such a device is in and of itself amoral, for it is knowledge and knowledge cannot be good nor evil, it has no volition. And two, such knowledge as exists will be discovered in due time by men far more likely to be seeking to answer other questions. For example, such a device might harness a great deal of energy. The ability to harness a great deal of energy would have very many uses, far more of them productive than sinister. Someone is far more likely to discover this energy phenomenon working on something else rather than deliberately go looking for the worst possible application from the onset.
"And yes, men have dug in the earth for a long time, however our history is full of discovering that substances long overlooked or unknown have many uses. It makes no economic sense for men to go search for that which they do not know exists, or know is valuable. For centuries many Europeans sat on vast coal, iron, and nickel deposits having no clue what they could possibly do with them, then suddenly great operations were underway seemingly everywhere at once when the revelation was made. As for the substance itself, I do not claim to be the singular expert, but no one knows all the mysteries of any one substance. Even water is curious and poses questions yet unanswered, as it defies all notions of how a liquid acts."