TheMonk:
I don't recall Lucifer being described as an Angel or fallen Angel in the Bible. I know that this one is frequently considered true amongst the general populace, but I'd like to have some sort of Canon reference for it...
There are Jewish texts (not part of the Bible, but still Canon), which detail the fall of Lucifer.
quote:
It is the first test. I certainly wouldn't use it to have the result be final regarding godhood, merely that it's an indicator.
Like I said, I think it's a terrible indicator. It's like saying "we will test if something is a pot by seeing if it is hot".
There are many things which are not gods which are prayed to.
There are many gods or false gods which are not prayed to.
There's little or no correlation between the two factors. Perhaps you are looking for 'worship'?
quote:
The second test is: Effect on the material world. Saints cannot directly effect the physical world, whereas demons/angels/Satan/God can.
According to Catholic canon, Saints CAN affect the material world. In fact, it's a requirement of being a Saint - they must have committed three miracles. Additionally, I can affect the material world, so perhaps I am a god too? However, several religions describe gods which have minimal observable effect on the material world.
quote:
I don't think it matters whether Satan refers to himself as a god. He could still be one.
Perhaps we should start with a definition of 'god'?
Even the definition is confused (looking up 'deity'):
quote:
A deity[1] is a recognised preternatural or supernatural immortal being, who may be thought of as holy, divine, or sacred, held in high regard, and respected by believers, often religiously referred to as a god.
Any supernatural, immortal creature? Of course not. Christianity (and a lot of other religions) believe we all have a supernatural, immortal soul. But we aren't all deities.
So figure out what you are trying to test, then we can figure out how to test for it.