Tooth and claw could also be a bit broad too I would be tempted to make it one or the other.

I really don't think it's too broad, considering that example specializations for Brawling listed are Wrestling, Boxing, Kung Fu, Karate, Kailindo and some others. It would be pretty much the same thing if your character was specialized in Melee weapons and picked Klaives as his specialization.

This is my thoughts exactly. I abhor min-maxers as the point of the game is the roleplay aspect. However, I also have strong feelings about specialties and how I (and apparently you Luke) interpret them.

It is the difference I noted earlier between boxing and simply throwing jabs.

Not to beat a dead horse, but Luke gets me. I see you

If I had to pick between the two, I would go with Claw as Razor Claws are one of my gifts.

Feats of Strength
Unlike other Attributes, Strength doesn’t usually
require a roll when a character performs some feat with
it. Instead, the chart below measures what a character
within a certain Strength range can normally accomplish.
If your character wants to do something that falls
within his Strength Attribute range, you don’t normally
need to make a roll. (Certain feats, like lifting and throwing
a table during a bar fight, may provide exceptions; in
this case, use Strength + Athletics or possibly Melee.)
To act outside his Strength range, however, you need to
make a Willpower roll, not a Strength roll. Generally, that
roll’s Difficulty is 9, although the Storyteller may raise
or lower it depending on the circumstances. For each
success, your character’s Strength is raised one step, up
to a maximum of five steps, during that turn and perhaps
for the next one as well — essentially for as long as it
takes to achieve that feat.
Botching a Strength feat’s Willpower roll can be
painful. At the Storyteller’s discretion, such botches may
inflict one health level’s worth of lethal damage for every
step of Strength the character had tried, and failed, to
reach. Jape, for example, might attempt to throw a cop’s
motorcycle — a Strength 6 feat. Currently in Homid form
(where she has Strength 3), she tries to push herself until
a botched roll inflicts three lethal health levels of damage
due to muscle strain. This damage cannot be soaked,
and must simply heal; thankfully, werewolves heal fast.

Dice Pool Feats Lift
1 Crush a soda can 40 lbs.
2 Break a chair 100 lbs.
3 Bust down a wooden door 250 lbs.
4 Break a two-by-four 400 lbs.
5 Smash open a metal fire door 650 lbs.
6 Throw a motorcycle 800 lbs.
7 Flip a small car 900 lbs.
8 Snap a lead pipe 1000 lbs.
9 Punch through a cement wall 1200 lbs.
10 Tear open a steel drum 1500 lbs.
11 Punch through 1” of sheet metal 2000 lbs.
12 Snap a streetlight post 3000 lbs.
13 Throw a sedan 4000 lbs.
14 Toss an SUV 5000 lbs.
15 Hurl a pickup truck 6000 lbs.

unbreakable
"adjective"
not liable to break or able to be broken easily.

Silver tongue:
"noun"
A tendency to be eloquent and persuasive in speaking.

Unbreakable with what roll/rolls would the 10's explode so to speak?

diplomatic
adjective
1.
of or concerning diplomacy.

diplomacy

noun

The art of dealing with people in a sensitive and tactful way.

Silver tongued is using charm to be persuasive doesn't mean you need to be sensitive or tactful to the other persons needs of feelings. How they feel might not align with what you are persuading them to do.

Players should clear any specialties with the
Storyteller, who can veto any specialties that are too broad
(such as “guns” for Firearms or “healing” for Medicine) or
that focus solely on game mechanics (“dealing damage”
for Strength or “soak rolls” for Stamina). The player and
Storyteller should work together to express the character’s
concept through specialties.

Specialties represent a particular
focus and proficiency related to the character’s
concept or profession.

It's why Ryan normally carries Boar's +2 Brawl bonus. He can give it up at need though.

Powerful: 10's count as 2 successes on rolls made for feats of strength
Lower Body: 10's count as 2 successes on rolls required for Jumping
High Tolerance: 10's count as 2 successes when rolling to soak silver
Tireless: 10's count as 2 successes when rolling physical endurance tests
Likeable: 10's count as 2 successes on social rolls with friends and allies
Hardened Gaze: 10's count as 2 successes with Facedown rolls
Uncanny Instincts: 10's count as 2 successes with sense rolls

I am re-canting the house ruling of reducing the diff to soak silver from 8 to 6 as I believe the one character with it is gaining an un fair advantage....

Spending Experience Points
Experience points are spent to increase Traits (most of
them, at least; see below). The chart in the sidebar shows
the various costs for each kind of Trait. Most costs are based
on the Trait’s current rating multiplied by a particular
number. If, for example, a player wanted to increase her
Politics from 3 to 4, it would cost six points, whereas a
Level Four tribe Gift would cost 12. If the player wants to
gain a new Ability the character doesn’t currently possess,
she pays three points to get the first dot. Traits can only
be raised by one dot per story.

EXPERIENCE CHART
Trait                                       Cost
Attribute                                 current rating x 4
Ability                                     current rating x 2
New Ability                              3
Gift                                        Level of Gift x 3
Gift from other breed/auspice/tribe Level of Gift x 5
Rage                                       current rating
Gnosis                                     current rating x 2
Willpower                                 current rating

Walking Between Worlds
Some supernatural creatures, including werewolves,
have learned methods of crossing the Gauntlet from the
physical world into the Umbra. All Garou have this Gaiagiven
ability — it’s their birthright, their legacy, and an
intuitive ability they inherit from the time of their First
Change. However, most werewolves are unaware of this
talent, and they usually don’t attempt it until an elder
shows them the way. Garou call this practice “stepping
sideways.”
Traveling through places where the Gauntlet is thick
is virtually impossible; crossing over where the Gauntlet
is thin comes as naturally as controlling one’s breathing.
Spiritualists can learn more exotic methods of crossing
this barrier, such as circumventing the Gauntlet entirely
by traveling to the spirit world in dreams. Mages and
other willworkers have their own methods for crossing
the Gauntlet; in fact, packs of werewolves may encounter
such visionaries on their travels.
System: To step sideways, a werewolf needs to meditate
on a highly reflective surface, such as a clear pool of
water or a mirror. When a character attempts this, roll
that character’s Gnosis; the difficulty is the strength of
the local Gauntlet. The Gauntlet is strongest near certain
types of environments; every place on Earth has a Gauntlet
rating between 2 and 9.
Gauntlet Chart
Area Difficulty Rating
Science lab 9
Inner city, downtown 8
Average city street 7
Rural countryside 6
Deep wilderness 5
Urban caern 5
Active caern 4
Powerful caern 3
Greatest caerns 2
Some shapeshifters cannot attempt this or have different
methods for crossing the Gauntlet. The time it takes
to enter the Umbra depends on the number of successes
on this Gnosis roll.
Successes Shift Time
Botch “Caught”
0 Failure (wait another hour before
trying again)
One 5 minutes
Two 30 seconds
Three+ Instantly
If the roll is botched, the werewolf is “caught” in the
Gauntlet, temporarily suspended between the mundane
Realm and the Umbra. He’s held in a web the Weaver
has woven until assisted by another Garou. Half of him
is spiritual, and half is physical. While trapped, he’s subjected
to soul-shattering visions. Although the werewolf
cannot be seen or attacked by physical entities (like
human beings), evil spirits wander the Gauntlet looking
for trapped and vulnerable travelers. Another werewolf
can attempt to free the traveler by making a successful
roll to step sideways; otherwise, the Garou must wait in
his shameful, dishonorable, and dangerous state for an
hour before trying again. If that second roll botches, he
cannot leave on his own. Until he’s rescued, he’s trapped
there forever.
Garou who have learned the Theurge Gift: Pulse of
the Invisible don’t need to use a reflective object when
stepping sideways; they can enter at will. Even blind
werewolves can enter the Umbra, as long as they know
that Gift. (At the Storyteller’s discretion, carrying your
own reflective object may make stepping sideways slightly
more difficult, since the object isn’t “anchored” to its
surroundings; in these cases, increase the difficulty by 1.)
Werewolves in a pack may choose one among them
to lead them into the Umbra; that individual makes the
Gnosis roll for all of them. (It’s usually the werewolf
with the highest Gnosis, who may in this instance act as
the temporary alpha of the pack.) If the pack is caught,
however, the shapechangers can make their second attempts
as individuals. Usually, the roll succeeds; all the
pack’s members arrive at the same time. All of the pack
members must be capable of stepping sideways, and they
must all be willing. Garou (or other shapechangers) who
are not part of the pack cannot travel with them; they
must travel through on their own. However, Garou with
the Theurge Gift: Grasp the Beyond can take non-Garou
with them into the Umbra.