Re: Charge!
Once the battle was joined, it quickly became obvious that the biggest threat the hobgoblins posed was as a group. The odd pincer maneuver of attacking from both sides is a bit more sophisticated than one expects from hobgoblins, but it was probably intended to take a few prisoners.
The three-squad countertactic is probably the best you could have done to disrupt the hobgoblin plans. It would now appear that they don't have any sort of real leader amongst them as they seem incapable of adjusting to the changing situation.
Aaron, out in the narrow valley, has no problem moving across the valley floor to get within medium range and fire off a shot at the other side.
03:24, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion, on behalf of Aaron Gray, rolled 10 using 1d20+3 ((7)).
His shot is close, but manages to miss the scattering hobgoblins.
Anneth continues to stay at range and fire arrows at the five hobgoblins that charged the riders.
Durek attacks the next hobgoblin that gets within range.
Elwood has no problem tying up one of the sleeping hobgoblins, although the act of tying him up rouses him out of the magical slumber. The rest of the hobgoblins continue to sleep; they aren't slinking off anywhere at the moment.
Geirdon now follows Durek's lead, engaging one of the remaining four hobgoblins that charged down the hill towards them.
Kareth knew he wasn't very good with a bow, certainly not from a galloping horse's back, so he kept low as they rode through the gauntlet. Probably as surprised as the others, he turns and chages back with the others, shooting his short bow at the nearest hobgoblin once it gets within range.
Rodrigo turns and gallops back, shooting at the hobgoblins, but also discovers that shooting a bow from galloping horseback is a bit harder than anticipated. The arrow misses its target.
Rukao, the party's own hobgoblin, feels a bit sorry that these other hobgoblins hadn't seemed interested in parlay, but at that point, they became the enemy and he has no qualms about battling them. He chose to forego using his bow and charged forward with the two Dwarves. The Dwarves got a slight jump on him, though, so now he waded in, taking on two of the remaining hobgoblins.
Talis, also charging back with the other riders, fires off a couple of shots from his bow. The first misses but the second hits, doing 3 points of damage to one of the hobgoblins.
Tom manages to decapitate the hobgoblin he attacked. That eliminates the last of the hobgoblins on the left.
Of course, now it's the hobgoblins' turn. The first eleven hobgoblins that were on the left have all been taken out. That leaves just the ten on the right, which split into two groups of five--one charged the riders, the other charged the Dwarves.
04:03, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 4,9 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((2,6)). Hobgoblin #12 closed with the riders but missed, however he was wounded by Anneth.
04:04, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 6,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((4,2)). Hobgoblin #13 closed with the riders but missed, however he was wounded by Anneth.
04:04, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 6,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((4,2)). Hobgoblin #14 closed with the riders but missed, however he was wounded by Talis.
04:05, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 8,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((6,2)). Hobgoblin #15 closed with the riders but missed.
04:06, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 12,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((10,2)). Hobgoblin #16 closed with the riders but missed, though he came the closest.
04:06, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 12,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((10,2)). Hobgoblin #17 charged the Dwarves, swung at Gierdon and missed.
Hobgoblin #18 charged the Dwarves and was quickly killed by Durek.
04:03, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 4,9 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((2,6)). Hobgoblin #19 charged the Dwarves and is now engaged with Durek; he misses.
04:05, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 8,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((6,2)). Hobgoblin #20 charged the Dwarves and swung at Rukao, but misses.
04:04, Sun 04 Jan 2015: Mysterion rolled 6,5 using 1d20+2,1d8+3 ((4,2)). Hobgoblin #21 charged the Dwarves and swung at Rukao, but misses.