Re: OOC3
You have it backwards. He provokes when he LEAVEs the squares we threaten, not enter. So I dont get an AoO on him when he moves into D6 but when he LEAVES to get into E5 he provokes from me.
Same thing from the bullywug. When he leaves B6 to go into A5, he provoked. As far as I know, they both 'leave' my threatened area at some point, meaning they both provoke (the bully and the chief). And that second attack was on the bullywug so I DO get a hit! (take that evil DM)
Now I confused myself on the third AoO cause I thought he provoked when he ENTERED my square. So We kinda got mixed up in a similar manner.
All in all, I missed enough that it wouldn't matter. I smacked the bullywug tho.
Also the Withdraw action. If the bUllywug 'withdraws' then he does not provoke any AoO when he leaves my threatened area. Same thing with the chief- he wouldnt provoke leaving from Harlis. BUT he would still provoke when leaving my threatened square.