Corros Graelor:
At this point we can still say "oops our bad." We did try to clarify about the sewer rat after all. A guy who builds dungeons with spectators might be a little out of our league at the moment. And I think we're running low on spells.
It's pretty apparent, by just looking at Thumek, that the man's a powerful spell-caster. Corros (after another good arcana roll) can see that Thumek's already got a couple of defensive spells in effect. Any attempt at reading Thumek's mind fails. And this is the butler.
You can still try to fight him, if you'd like. You can try to talk to him. Or you can just leave.
I'm going to be visiting family in the Washington D.C. area starting tomorrow. I'll have internet access during that week but my availability will be spotty and I won't have any of my rulebooks so things will probably slow down until I get back home.
-