Feedback.   Posted by DM.Group: 0
DM
 GM, 71 posts
 The Prophet
Tue 28 Jun 2016
at 23:13
Feedback
So, this has existed for more or less a week now, we've all picked classes and races and we're working out how we're all going to fit together. Ylanaria Soon, I'll be creating an additional spell list for Baehaen and Lorin individually to beef them out with Warcraft-themed spells from the World of Warcraft RPG.

I've been slaving away at reformatting the spells that I got and I got a lot of inspiration while doing it, but one of the things that sets Play-by-Post games apart is that there's not as much instant feedback to the things you present your players. So I have no idea if you guys appreciate the stuff I'm giving you for this campaign or if there's something you'd like to see changed.

Do you guys have anything to voice? It'd be nice to hear anything. Compliments, criticisms. I'm not desperate for approval, but it's really weird not knowing how people feel about the stuff you make.
TheJagster
 player, 19 posts
 Akecheta Runetotem
Tue 28 Jun 2016
at 23:19
Feedback
I'm digging what you've been doing so far. You have definitely taken the time to ask several questions of the players, and really help us think more about our backgrounds and what not. I definitely appreciate the emphasis you've been placing on story, and that rewards/goals thread you put up today was pretty sweet :)

Keep up the good work!
Lynette
 player character, 24 posts
Tue 28 Jun 2016
at 23:28
Feedback
Nothing kills a game like an inactive GM and you, my friend, are definitely not one of those. Keep up the activity and this game will be a smashing success.

I'm ready to begin at any time.
Vargh Bladefury
 player character, 1 post
Wed 29 Jun 2016
at 05:00
Feedback
No, you are doing fine, though I feel like I am falling behind slightly, but that is always the case when I am doing character creation.

I love the thematics that you have presented thus far, and I appreciate the consideration you have for our characters.
Ieroklis Tsiranidis
 player, 19 posts
 Lorin Sunheart
Wed 29 Jun 2016
at 13:31
Feedback
everything looks good, can't wait to get started! :)
Trask84
 player, 12 posts
 Basung Gold Fist
Wed 29 Jun 2016
at 15:35
Feedback
PRO:  you as a DM are really active and commited, I see a lot of great character concepts
CON: We haven't started yet :p  and the website format makes it a little chaotic and difficult to really forge bonds before we start
DM
 GM, 73 posts
 The Prophet
Thu 30 Jun 2016
at 10:32
Feedback
I'm really glad to hear that! I can't wait to get started either. I have some interesting encounters planned for you guys! I can't wait to see all of your sheets. :)

I still have some spells which I need to introduce to our casters. I was thinking of making it a Google Document instead, since the forum format, as Trask explained, is kind of chaotic.
Baehean Nightreaver
 player character, 13 posts
Sun 10 Jul 2016
at 13:33
Feedback
That is what I get for posting from my Ipad and missing part of a post....
Baehean Nightreaver
 player character, 15 posts
Sun 10 Jul 2016
at 13:37
Feedback
Please note I am not being an ass or what not, just that Baehean is adjusting and a tad off from what one would normally expect.
DM
 GM, 108 posts
 The Prophet
Tue 19 Jul 2016
at 23:50
Feedback
Guys, I'll just be brutal about this: I'm not very happy with the lurking behavior that I see. I put up the deadlines as to force myself to keep pace, but that's becoming increasingly difficult if 4 of 7 people aren't actively participating. Despite the deadlines, I still find myself waiting for more input. I'm not here to tell a story at you, I'm here to tell a story with you.

Please start posting.
DM
 GM, 109 posts
 The Prophet
Wed 20 Jul 2016
at 00:02
Feedback
Is this how things work here? Am I not going fast enough? This is pretty upsetting, I put a lot of energy into this campaign.
Lynette
 player character, 44 posts
Wed 20 Jul 2016
at 00:58
Feedback
The posts are fast enough, but the story doesn't seem to be progressing.