IID - The Absence of Law
Brady pauses to consider the first of Lee’s questions. ”That question has bothered me since Mr. Tunstall first came to Lincoln. Since the first of the troubles started.”
He shrugs helplessly. ”The fact is, I don’t know. I’ve spoken about it with Michael Kibbee, the man who publishes the local newspaper. Read some of the back issues he’s stored. I even went so far as to make inquires with some of the territorial authorities the last time I was in Santa Fe. “
“No one can give me a satisfactory answer. Mr. Murphy came to New Mexico originally intending to make his living as a hunter and guide. He was part of a wagon train that met with disaster trying to cross through the Capitan Mountains. The only one to survive the trek. After that, he settled here, in the Rio Bonito Valley, where he slowly began investing in property. As best I can tell, Ranger Lee, he was well off even before he entered the cattle business.”
“But here is what bothers me the most. Not long after Mr. Tunstall established his ranch and store in Lincoln, I had occasion to speak with Captain Ayuso, commander of the barracks at Roswell. She told me that between the Confederate Army here and in Arizona, along with the rail lines such as Lone Star, there was enough of a beef market for both Mr, Murphy and Mr. Tunstall to sell every steer on their range. And to the best of my knowledge, that hasn’t changed.”
“So, in light of that, I honestly don’t know why Mr. Murphy would have wanted Mr. Tunstall killed...or driven out of Lincoln.”
He sighs, giving a regretful smile. ”If I had a free hand in this, Ranger, I think I would look into two things. Men like Jesse Evans...you know the cloth they’re cut from. They’re outlaws and they will always cleave to those same, terrible habits. It is in their nature. In time, they will make mistakes. Catching them is a matter of watching and waiting.”
“But were I looking, I would want to know more of James Dolan, Mr. Murphy’s right hand man. He handles most of Mr. Murphy’s public affairs and is clearly intimately involved in all of his businesses. Mr. Murphy is a closed book. Difficult to draw near to. Mr. Dolan, I think, is a different matter.”
“And I would want to know more of Mr. Murphy’s terrible experience with that ill fated wagon train. Call me foolish, Ranger Lee, but I believe that is where that is where everything involving this valley began for him.”