Victoriously to Phandalan
The party gathered their things and made their way back to the hidden entrance to the Redbrand's hideout. Finding it was easy enough as it was not really all that well hidden, it just happened to be a place that few people were ever likely to stumble onto it. They found the cellar-like doors open, which seemed somewhat odd on one hand, but on the other they couldn't actually remember if they had bothered closing it when last they used it.
Regardless, they proceeded down into the long tunnel, extra cautious to start with (just in case) before relaxing a bit for the sake of saving time since they'd seen no definitive signs that others had been here. It was pitch black in this tunnel, so Morgan lit a torch and held it aloft for all to see as best they could.
When they arrived at the cellar, things immediately looked different. To start, all of the wall sconces had burned out, leaving even this in pitch darkness. Shadows danced about all around you in the light of the torch. You heard no sounds and neither saw nor hear hears any sign of life.
The Redbrand captain's instructions had been pretty clear. If you were to find the family in their cell, you would need to cross to the western side of the chasm and then go to the northeast corner to find them. There were traps if you came at it from the south east, but there was a hidden door if you went up the chasm and came in from the northwest.
As the group set out to follow their instructions, preparing to cross the chasm, they were struck by a surprising sight - the one eyed creature laid dead just inside the lip of the chasm, deep cuts and punctures into his torso, and a slice the clove through his jaw and up into the lower part of his brain.
There was no memory to have mixed up with that bit - the group certainly had not killed this creature before they left.
Someone else had been here since last you left!