Backtracking a little bit to share some random thoughts on the race/species topic:
Dungeon Master:
Another idea rattling around in my head is that, after a setting where racial tension was so at the fore, maybe we experiment with something where it's a non-issue? I was thinking that would dovetail nicely with Fergus's desire to play a goblin paladin, but maybe not, if the point is specifically to play something off-type?
Dungeon Master:
Came across this thread about race in D&D on Twitter today, thought it was interesting and relevant to some things I've been thinking about when plotting the next campaign. Author is Keith Ammann, author of The Monsters Know What They're Doing.
I'm cool with a setting conceit that racial differences are essentially a non-issue, or at least not a central theme. There might still be dwarves who dislike elves and elves who think all halflings are thieves, but it doesn't go much beyond character quirks.
However, even in an egalitarian society that accepts all races I can see people still having issue with goblins,
IF the standard D&D goblin lore applies. If goblins are rare in civil society and the predominant goblin disposition/culture is of malicious, cannibalistic murderers then it's understandable that people are concerned seeing a goblin in town! Same would go for drow, lizardfolk, kobolds, duergar, orcs, changelings, etc. that are similarly 'default evil' in the lore and good specimens are treated as exceptions. There could be room for both if all such races are already integrated into civil society, with the evil versions existing as hostile factions
because they're evil, not because of race. Therefore, your friendly goblin neighbor has nothing to do with the Bone-Skewer Marauders goblinoid tribe killing people on the other side of the valley :P
With all that said, I think Mr. Amman makes a great point that the factual differences between D&D races/species would impact society, but I also think that taking that into account could easily lead right back to racial tensions :P However, perhaps our egalitarian fantasy society could celebrate such differences rather than treating them as points of division! Maybe tieflings are regarded as the best metalworkers because of fire resistance, drow are respected as the best nighttime/underground scouts because of super-darkvision, firbolgs are considered authoritative in gardening and animal husbandry since they can speak to plants and animals, and so on.
This message was last edited by the player at 21:42, Fri 02 Sept 2022.