Qadar:
I'm going to take my dig at 4th edition when I can and say it's like playing a computer game character on tabletop.
Well, yes, I suppose but without the computer to do 90% of the work for you. So not like that at all :).
Qadar:
I also prefer puzzles and roleplaying. I'm trying to see if there is an ecology here for one, if the "Carrion Crawler" eats the Stirges and the hermit you found uses its stench to keep them away. I hope that encounters in this setting influence each other.
You know, I had just been thinking the same thing. The ecology rating is strong in this area of Arden Vul. Steady supply of 1st level adventurers -> centipedes/stirges/crawler -> Lankios. You can't really think of it as a sustainable ecosystem but it's close enough to be satisfying.
~~~
I'm not a fan of AD&D thieves and feel Sil, even though triple-classed, provides enough of the skulking. That was one of the major advancements of 4th edition: upgrading rogues. Right now, the party would most benefit from another bruiser.
I guess I like AD&D combat more than most of you (but no more, necessarily, than the other offerings of Arden Vul).