Out of Character Thread 2
I don't think my knowledge is superior, I am just old and pedantic! :-)
The old "Vancian" memorise/cast/forget system was OK at high levels when the caster had a pile of spells to use. But at low levels it was really boring. "I cast Sleep", then the rest of the adventuring day is "I throw dagger/dart".
Lots of grognards try to paint it as "This is the way", but the the truth is, we were all coming up with house rules to give the mage more options. As a player, I always played multi-class, so I could cast my one spell, and then at least still be useful!
With the huge swing in popularity the last few years, there have been a lot of books and documentaries about the history of D&D. Unfortunately, there seems to be the ones that favour Arneson and slag Gygax; and the ones that do the opposite.
I have read a few, but the ones that I trust are by Jon Peterson. Playing with the World is a huge slog, it is very textbook-like and very long. Game Wizards is much more readable, and much shorter. He relies on documents as opposed to just talking to people, which is to remove bias as best he can.