Re: OOC Chatter (1)
In reply to Nerull (msg # 341):
you know, I play on two others games on rpol, sometimes for years, and with those groups we tried the private messages between GMs and players; we tried to make the private messages public with the "spoil" format... All our experiments led to the same conclusion :
MAKE IT PUBLIC.
- it makes the thread alive, interesting, and not filled with boring "PM" :)
- we get to know our respective characters
- a message with only one recipient is a waste of writing time ;
- when a player gets a "private but interesting" information, he shares it 99% of the times. Thats's another waste of time (even more time lost if he's supposed to share the info, but forgets to do so)
EDIT : if the player shares the info "in-character", he may lose some of the info. For example, when Alyx texted his findings to Andrew, it wasn't integral (was the text message limited to 128 characters? ;)) he did not mention the bit about the ad's contact information :) If Alyx's player is afk, nobody knows that bit. :/
- it avoids many misunderstandings, and requests "where are you", "whatudoing" "why do you that" :)
- it's generally obvious if a message information is known only by a player. If needed, the other players are able to distinguish between what they know and what their characters know.
Even when the other players aren't supposed to know a very precise info (the PC involved is an expert, not the other PCs...), the rest of the message helps as status reminder and background info.
I'm not saying "the chaotic evil assassin/antipaladin PC HAS TO share his plans to backstabb everyone of you", but if the likely action is to share the info, could we skip the "I share with the team" chatter? :)
Could we also avoid the unnecessary headaches brought by those considerations ? "who did communicate with whom ? Are you aware of this? You were 5 steps behind the group, you could not have heard what X said. Who did told you? Nobody repeated it to you! Nobody knows your whereabouts because you did not specify you updated your position to the team every five minutes! You're still on the planet when everybody else is leaving with the ship because nobody stated they contacted you..."
There is absolutely no reason Alyx wouldn't share his findings. I suggest that we assume our characters share any info the GM gives us, and welcome advice/help/support in return, unless stated otherwise. :)
This message was last edited by the player at 09:49, Thu 24 Sept 2020.