Bartimaeus:
But as to whether I "wish to commit it" shouldn't be a unilateral decision: Tegan and Yshtar, what do you think? But more(?) importantly, DM, this is your city: is this a road you want to go down, not having prepared it?
It’s my city, but this is all of your (your’s? Yours’?) game. There is a DEFINITE path and story hook here, as a part of the conclusion you came to may absolutely hold water. It’s a conclusion you came to before any of the other clues leading to it were presented, however, which is what threw me off originally. Basically, having said it out loud in front the presence of some of the NPCs around you guys currently, there’s going to be reactions to it amongst them.
Basically, I’m hesitant to say too much here. Whereas the encounter you were heading toward with Nethroth’zul was something you could easily walk away from at the last moment, the circumstances of this are a little different. That’s all. I hate railroading my players, but the current situation isn’t really the sort that can be just dropped, given the circumstances of where you all are and how you got there.
So I’d say just play it by ear and do what your characters would do. I’m really interested to see how this goes.