Player 2:
The P.V.F. math is... funky.
Hopefully in the sense that you have to calculate differently in a bunch of places. I tried to model it with relatively quick piece-wise functions so that it would end up sensible, unlike the BP method. The BP method given is very simple, but it also egregiously disagrees with all the values presented throughout the books; the result being that you can get screwed over by the BP system or use it to splurge, depending on how well you know how messed up it is.
Player 2:
Replacing Covenant BP with PvF leaves you with... BP rules
Try calculating with BP how much it costs to have your covenant start with a single copy of the Bible or the Qu'ran. Meanwhile, calculate how many pawns of Creo vis you could get for the same BP. Then note that a single pawn of Creo vis can buy you 20 copies of either of those if you exchange the pawn for silver with the Redcaps. That's why I recalculated.
Player 17:
And while with Magic Theory 4, he can serve as a lab assistant, it would really be a waste of his actual abilities. Javan has served the Order for over a hundred years. During that time he has been a lab assistant for maybe a total of five years.
For clarity, a score in Magic Theory is a necessary condition to work as a lab assistant, but it is not a sufficient condition. You need that as well as something that qualifies him. He could work as a lab servant. He could set up labs. He could copy Hermetic books. He could write books on Magic Theory. But he could not work as a genuine lab assistant.
... Looks like that was probably all figured out.