Due to a complete accident on both my part and Asha's, we're gonna have to shift gears. Question is: how?

A: Set up the scene to look like old-school hunters (such as Leopold) attacked.

B: Have Asha's player create a new character and have them save Asha for a later part of the game where she becomes an enemy, and have an IC election to see which of the Primogen ends up becoming the new Prince.
This message was last edited by the GM at 23:46, Sat 20 Nov 2021.

In reply to Storyteller (msg # 1):

I vote B as Richard has rightly said there is no reason Nef and his character could work with Asha after their prince attacked her and the anarch elders killed the sherrif and primogen. Better to presume there was some nefarious plan by the anarch elders or something and have anew camarilla character join to support them due to the uncertain times. Also im sure several character/ players might enjoy killing Asha at some point in the future XD

Gonna miss baxter but a small price to play for the game to continue without completely compromising the characters thoughts and actions etc. I'l start working on cam character as i predict this will be the chosen option and even if by some strnage miracle it isn't its always good to have a spare haha

Rook would be ambivalent about it.  He's an independent Gangrel, and holds no alliegences to either side.  Also, they had the right to defend themselves, so Rook would not be taking sides against them on ethical grounds.  I don't see why Asha needs to return as a villain, but that could be fun if Asha would enjoy it.
I could definitely see the Primogen electing a new Prince IC.

I'm gonna have to see what the others would vote, but as far as Nefertiti is concerned they all should be put to Final Death.  Now the question is who is going to do the act?

Killing the Prince for attacking a wild woman and the Anarch Elders for killing two members of the Carmilla.

Being a high profiler in the Carmilla and a high ranking Tremere, she would want to see the Law be taken upon all involved.

In reply to Nefertari Panthea (msg # 4):

Technically they would need to kill Asha too, though she only acted to defend herself, and has not killed yet.

I could easily go along with killing the Anarch Elders, and the Prince.  Asha, however, does not deserve punishment.

I was going for All parties involved to meet Final Death.

Why have Laws if they are not abide by

In reply to Nefertari Panthea (msg # 6):

I figured you were.  :)

Why follow unjust laws?

The Law is Just.

All Kindreds would know not to start trouble in marked places.