Link:
Question: How does sharing merits work in this game?
It seems we are starting with shared premises.
Mechanical:
Can we spend extra xp on them?
If yes, how do we calculate this?
Example:
A and decide to buy 2 more dots of library that already has one dot
a) Each buys a dot and pays 2xp
b) Buying a second dot costs 4xp (paid by A) and the third one costs 6xp (paid by B)
c) A and B each pay 5xp
d) Each player buys a full merit (A: library, B: Hallow), then shares it
Are two shared 1-dot Hallows cheaper than 1 2-dot Halllow?
Which merits are shareable? Merits? Safe place? Retainer? Library? Allies? Hallow?
Hi there!
Based on your example, it would be closes to Case A. If player A spends 2 xp to invest in Library, and then player B spends 2 xp to invest a dote in Library as well, the total shared Library would be at 3 dots since it started with 1.
Hallows are quite rare, but still a shared merit that follows the rules stated above. That said, you wouldn't just be able to buy another Hallow in the same Sanctum, beyond the 1-dot Hallow already found in the Sanctum. There are ways to create/improve hallows via spells and other ways, which would be necessary in order to invest further XP into the existing Hallow.
"Housing merits" are generally shareable (e.g. Sanctum, Library, Hallow, Alchemical Lab, Scriptorium, etc.) but other Social Merits like Allies, Contacts, Retainers and the like are not.