RolePlay onLine RPoL Logo

, welcome to Sci-Fi Worldbuilding: The Game!

12:55, 26th April 2024 (GMT+0)

OOC Thread.

Posted by The GMFor group 0
Xadir
player, 39 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 13:19
  • msg #160

Re: OOC Thread

Daryus:
Just picking nits, but if Hapids are the only culture that seems to use gladiators... wouldn't that make the hapid gladiator the standard rather than an outlier? Also, based on the description, are hapid gladiators all men? Since only the males are rabbits and it mentions high jumps as part of the style. Or would there be divergent styles for males and females and even a neutral style?

Fine with the other two. Stormriders read as wizard/cleric combo, yeah. Divination focus? Somewhat shamanistic.

It's telling how much we all think in D&D classes.

Other than that, fine to move on.


Yeah that class was my design.

So I'll answer the questions.

Cats are better jumpers then Rabbits in the real world and I don't see why either Sex would be prevented to use high jumps of the gladiator style itself. I honestly did think of making the Gladiator style more specific but that's more so I could imagine so many class variants it wasn't even funny.

Gladiators are a class in other Games, hence why I named them Hapid gladiators. While they might be the common Gladiator in this World, I wanted a distinction to be made.
This message was last edited by the player at 13:45, Tue 14 June 2022.
The GM
GM, 89 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 13:58
  • msg #161

Re: OOC Thread

Daryus:
Since only the males are rabbits and it mentions high jumps as part of the style. Or would there be divergent styles for males and females and even a neutral style?


On one hand, I like the idea of divergent styles.

On the other hand, who says cats can't jump? Have you ever seen a cat jump? They're better at jumping than I am, I tell you what.

Daryus:
Fine with the other two. Stormriders read as wizard/cleric combo, yeah. Divination focus? Somewhat shamanistic.


Actually, I was referring to the Spirit Shamans as the Cleric/Mage combo, but sure, whatever floats your turtle.

Daryus:
It's telling how much we all think in D&D classes.


And yet kinda unsurprising, too.
The GM
GM, 90 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 15:24
  • msg #162

Re: OOC Thread

ROUND SEVEN: FINAL ROUND

1 faction (1 per player)

--Each player will describe one faction that exists in the fantasy world. Each faction can be relatively small (a company of mercenaries, or an enclave of three powerful mages (and their lackeys, if any)) or large (a cult, or a guild of merchants (or thieves and/or beggars)). Each faction should have something that makes them a bit unique.

--DO NOT SUGGEST THINGS THAT ARE EXACTLY LIKE A FACTION THAT ALREADY EXISTS IN D&D/PATHFINDER/ANYWHERE ELSE.

--Top three recipients of votes will become officially canon as existing in the fantasy world.

And one more thing:

--There is no prohibition against your faction being evil if you want. The heroes gotta fight some sentient beings, sometimes, over more than just big misunderstandings, after all.
Xadir
player, 40 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 21:01
  • msg #163

Re: OOC Thread

Can i just say, that the 3,2,1,0 system with no additional 0's just feels nice?
The GM
GM, 91 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 23:55
  • msg #164

Re: OOC Thread

Xadir:
Can i just say, that the 3,2,1,0 system with no additional 0's just feels nice?


?

No additional 0s?

Or are you saying you like 321 better than when we do 332211? Or...? (What are you saying? I'm glad you approve, but of what...?)
Xadir
player, 41 posts
Tue 14 Jun 2022
at 23:57
  • msg #165

Re: OOC Thread

The GM:
Xadir:
Can i just say, that the 3,2,1,0 system with no additional 0's just feels nice?


?

No additional 0s?

Or are you saying you like 321 better than when we do 332211? Or...? (What are you saying? I'm glad you approve, but of what...?)

No Additional 0s.
The GM
GM, 92 posts
Wed 15 Jun 2022
at 00:52
  • msg #166

Re: OOC Thread

Xadir:
The GM:
Xadir:
Can i just say, that the 3,2,1,0 system with no additional 0's just feels nice?


?

No additional 0s?

Or are you saying you like 321 better than when we do 332211? Or...? (What are you saying? I'm glad you approve, but of what...?)

No Additional 0s.


I don't get it. What does that mean?
Xadir
player, 42 posts
Wed 15 Jun 2022
at 00:56
  • msg #167

Re: OOC Thread

I'm sorry for confusing you. The No Additional 0's does two things that feel nicer one it's a straight ranking list, thus emotions are easier to judge the overall pieces.

While the other aspect is I only feel responsible for one thing if it fails to go through. I feel more content in my even mild support, and am relieved when the 0 comes through anyway, even if it wasn't what I'd prefer of the bunch.
The GM
GM, 96 posts
Thu 16 Jun 2022
at 20:28
  • msg #168

Re: OOC Thread


Waiting to hear back from someone about a question I have
The GM
GM, 99 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 00:52
  • msg #169

Re: OOC Thread


ROUND SEVEN: FINAL ROUND: FACTIONS is up.

To help avoid the need for tiebreaking, give 3 points to one entry, and then 2 to another, and then 1 to another. (It may not succeed in avoiding a tie, but at least it seems fair.)

PM me your votes.

Do NOT vote for your own submission at all.
The GM
GM, 101 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 14:16
  • msg #170

Re: OOC Thread


One more person left to vote...
Xadir
player, 43 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 17:56
  • msg #171

Re: OOC Thread

Is it just me, or does everyone else see the interconnection between those 3 groups?
The GM
GM, 103 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 17:56
  • msg #172

Re: OOC Thread

And, the round is over, and all voting is over.

There was a tie, but breaking it didn't involve my entry, so I broke it myself.

So, I can now announce who's won this little contest...

...I don't actually KNOW who's won the contest yet, because I haven't done the math. It's READY to do, but, like, so...

...How much transparency do you want, here?

1. TOTAL TRANSPARENCY: Walk us through each step of the math, GM.

2. VERY THOROUGH NON-TRANSPARENCY: Walk us through each step of the math, but don't reveal who submitted which entries.

3. THOROUGH NON-TRANSPARENCY: Show us exactly what the final vote totals add up to.

4. WHO CARES ABOUT TRANSPARENCY: Just tell us who won, GM! I don't even care who came in second place!
Xadir
player, 44 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 17:57
  • msg #173

Re: OOC Thread

TOTAL TRANSPARENCY, i prefer knowing the exact math, and knowing who goes to which submission means I can root for someone else.
This message was last edited by the player at 18:26, Fri 17 June 2022.
The GM
GM, 104 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 18:38
  • msg #174

Re: OOC Thread

Xadir:
TOTAL TRANSPARENCY, i prefer knowing the exact math, and knowing who goes to which submission means I can root for someone else.


Someone give me another opinion. If it's the same as Xadir's, I'll do it that way.
Balance
player, 15 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 21:01
  • msg #175

Re: OOC Thread

Xadir:
TOTAL TRANSPARENCY, i prefer knowing the exact math, and knowing who goes to which submission means I can root for someone else.


Ditto.

Regardless who won or lost, I guess we all contributed to a new fantasy setting, for good or bad...
Xadir
player, 45 posts
Fri 17 Jun 2022
at 21:09
  • msg #176

Re: OOC Thread

I don't believe there were any stakes either, so the World's all that's really important in the end.

Personally, I suspect I'll get third place since that's where I seemed to fall most of the time.
This message was last edited by the player at 22:00, Fri 17 June 2022.
The GM
GM, 105 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 01:23
  • msg #177

Re: OOC Thread


Okay then HERE WE GO

(Balance) Smokeweed 10
(Daryus) Archanaea 7
Giant Blues 5
(WO) Decadent Soldier 4
(Xadir) Infestor: 4


Balance 10
Daryus 7
Me 5
WO  4
Xadir 4



(Daryus) The Sandstone Desert: 8
(Daryus) The Amerylith Coast: 8
(Xadir) The Village of Nature's Chessboard: 8
(Balance) Endless Mines: 7
(Balance) The Cursed Island: 6
(Me) Pendrell: 6 points
(Xadir) The Ring of Light: 6
(World's) Wilco's Unseen Tear: 5
(Me) The Khavos Dunes: 4
(World's) Woods Of The West: 2


Balance 10 7 6 = 23
Daryus 7 8 8 = 23
Me 5 6 4 = 15
WO  4 5 2 = 11
Xadir 4 6 8 = 18




(Daryus) Waveriders: 10
(Me) The Uglolla: 9
(World's) The Endless Mine's Nomads: 8
(Xadir) The Grand Frog Monarchy: 6
(World's) Folk of the Cage: 6
(Daryus) The City of Night: 5
(Xadir) The Hapids: 5
(Balance) The Islands Confederacy: 5
(Balance) Kirland: 3
(Me) The Sabral: 3


Balance 23 7 6 = 36
Daryus 23 8 8 = 39
Xadir 18 6 8 = 32
Me 15 6 4 = 25
WO  11 2 5 = 18



(World's) The Man 8
(Me) Noric 8
(Me) Ossiga, the Ghost Queen 7
(Balance) Bor’Ma 6
(Daryus) The Grand Lizard 6
(Daryus) That-Which-Thrashes-in-the-Deep 6
(Xadir) The Chessmaster 5
(Xadir) Anabt 5
(Balance) The Dragon King 5
(World's) King of the Desert 4



Daryus 39 6 6 = 51
Balance 36 5 6 = 47
Xadir 32 5 5 = 42
Me 25 8 7 = 40
WO  18 8 4 = 30




(Xadir) Trait Stones: 10
(Balance) Star Steel: 6
(Me) Belt and Scabbard of Thunderbolt: 5
(Daryus) The Shell of Orkan-Mahru: 4
(World's) Advisor's Stone: 4



Daryus 51 4 = 55
Balance 47 6 = 53
Xadir 42 10 = 52
Me 40 5 = 45
WO 30 4 = 34



(Me) Spirit Shaman: 9
(Daryus) Stormriders: 8
(Xadir) Hapid Gladiator: 6
(World's) Inheritor: 5
(Balance) Miners: 2

Daryus 55 8 = 63
Balance 53 2 = 55
Xadir 52 6 = 58
Me 45 9 = 54
WO 34 5 = 39



(Me) The Cautious Ones (Lawful Neutral Faction): 11
(Worlds) The Turkeys: 5
(Xadir) The Dungeon Builders: 5
(Daryus) The Cult of Den'Ghra: 5
(Balance) The Wanderers: 4

Daryus 63 5 = 68
Xadir 58 5 = 63
Balance 55 4 = 59
Me 54 11 = 65
WO 39 5 = 44

Final Scores:

Daryus 68
Me 65
Xadir 63
Balance 59
WO 44

IF my math is right, I almost caught up to Daryus in the end... but not quite.

Is my math right?
Xadir
player, 46 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 01:27
  • msg #178

Re: OOC Thread

I'm going to make a sheet, to double Check Real Quick.
Xadir
player, 47 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 02:10
  • msg #179

Re: OOC Thread

Ok, i didn't just double check, because I saw I got a different result, and had accidentally missed one, while I was triple verifying that particular result, so I did it a different way by simply grouping all Entries as well.

https://docs.google.com/spread...s4V56BKhQ/edit#gid=0

World
(WO) Decadent Soldier 4
(World's) Wilco's Unseen Tear: 5
(World's) Woods Of The West: 2
(World's) The Endless Mine's Nomads: 8
(World's) Folk of the Cage: 6
(World's) The Man 8
(World's) King of the Desert 4
(World's) Advisor's Stone: 4
(World's) Inheritor: 5
(Worlds) The Turkeys: 5

4+5+2+8+6+8+4+4+5+5=51

GM:
(Me) The Cautious Ones (Lawful Neutral Faction): 11
(Me) Spirit Shaman: 9
(Me) Belt and Scabbard of Thunderbolt: 5
Giant Blues 5
(Me) Pendrell: 6 points
(Me) The Khavos Dunes: 4
(Me) The Uglolla: 9
(Me) The Sabral: 3
(Me) Noric 8
(Me) Ossiga, the Ghost Queen 7

11+9+5+5+6+4+9+3+8+7=67

Xadir
(Xadir) Infestor: 4
(Xadir) The Village of Nature's Chessboard: 8
(Xadir) The Ring of Light: 6
(Xadir) The Grand Frog Monarchy: 6
(Xadir) The Hapids: 5
(Xadir) The Chessmaster 5
(Xadir) Anabt 5
(Xadir) Trait Stones: 10
(Xadir) Hapid Gladiator: 6
(Xadir) The Dungeon Builders: 5

4+8+6+6+5+5+5+10+6+5=60

Daryus
(Daryus) Archanaea 7
(Daryus) The Sandstone Desert: 8
(Daryus) The Amerylith Coast: 8
(Daryus) Waveriders: 10
(Daryus) The City of Night: 5
(Daryus) The Grand Lizard 6
(Daryus) That-Which-Thrashes-in-the-Deep 6
(Daryus) The Shell of Orkan-Mahru: 4
(Daryus) Stormriders: 8
(Daryus) The Cult of Den'Ghra: 5

7+8+8+10+5+6+6+4+8+5=67

Balance
(Balance) Smokeweed 10
(Balance) Endless Mines: 7
(Balance) The Cursed Island: 6
(Balance) The Islands Confederacy: 5
(Balance) Kirland: 3
(Balance) Bor’Ma 6
(Balance) The Dragon King 5
(Balance) Star Steel: 6
(Balance) Miners: 2
(Balance) The Wanderers: 4

10+7+6+5+3+6+5+6+2+4=54






Both Went the Exact Same.

Daryus, and The Gm had 67
I had 60
Balance had 54
World had 51.

I might be wrong, but I think I have done enough verification, and made it fairly easy for anyone to double check my results, by grouping all entries together, and allowing them to see the math equation. Heck, I triple Checked both of the Ways I did the Math.


So, The Gm did catch up to Daryus, he didn't surpass however. As Both Daryus, and The Gm Won. And as I had long since Suspected I got third.
This message was last edited by the player at 02:15, Sat 18 June 2022.
Xadir
player, 48 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 02:44
  • msg #180

Re: OOC Thread

Also I do believe something Else is amiss.

I believe there is one point unaccounted for.

For every contest 30 points total was awarded, for all double contests you can treat them as two separate contests, for a total of 10.

Each person gave out 6 points during each contest, and 5 people played.

Now, no matter which reading you go, even if I'm wrong on the totals at the End, an interesting point arises, both mine and the Gm's were off by 1, 1 point is unaccounted for, and very well might be what solves the Tie.




For math purposes.

Gm's Results
300-68-65-63-59-44=1 you can just look at the 3 odds, to see it doesn't equal an even.

Daryus 68
Me 65
Xadir 63
Balance 59
WO 44




My Results

300-67-67-60-54-51=1 Same parity issue, easily identifiable even without going through the math.

Daryus 67
The Gm had 67
I had 60
Balance had 54
World had 51.


Edit: Heck, I can even prove which round the issue propped out on.






(Xadir) Trait Stones: 10
(Balance) Star Steel: 6
(Me) Belt and Scabbard of Thunderbolt: 5
(Daryus) The Shell of Orkan-Mahru: 4
(World's) Advisor's Stone: 4



It was this one Contest, where a parity issue Arised.

Note it should be impossible for only one vote to have an odd number.
This message was last edited by the player at 03:04, Sat 18 June 2022.
Daryus
player, 26 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 03:04
  • msg #181

Re: OOC Thread

OK, I am fine with the tie. Haha. I forgot there was this part. If I had recalled it, I wouldn't be surprised as many of my ideas got through to the canon.

Interesting results.
Xadir
player, 49 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 03:05
  • msg #182

Re: OOC Thread

Though, Now there's a mystery afoot. The mystery of the missing point.
Daryus
player, 27 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 03:10
  • msg #183

Re: OOC Thread

Possibly a result of just missing a vote? Guess it might matter. I was partaking more to build a world.

However, if that missing point is nagging at you, gotta recount that round. Not sure how organized everyone else was with voting, but all my votes were cast using a single PM thread, so mine should be easy to track.

Gotta admit, there were more than one round where I didn't want to vote for third place at all.
Xadir
player, 50 posts
Sat 18 Jun 2022
at 03:16
  • msg #184

Re: OOC Thread

Daryus:
Possibly a result of just missing a vote? Guess it might matter. I was partaking more to build a world.

However, if that missing point is nagging at you, gotta recount that round. Not sure how organized everyone else was with voting, but all my votes were cast using a single PM thread, so mine should be easy to track.

Gotta admit, there were more than one round where I didn't want to vote for third place at all.

Single pm

3:
2:
1:

Should be easy to do, for me as well.

The Second bit is Quite Harsh.
This message was last edited by the player at 03:18, Sat 18 June 2022.
Sign In