Re: OOC#2
A long response- skip to the bottom if you do not want to go all the way through it.
I agree- Web would be fantastic, provided we could target them without also webbing ourselves up. But as they made point to completely surround us almost as soon as we met, it seems that would not have been possible. And web is a second level spell, unlike the more accessible first level sleep, so V would be the only one who could cast it anyway. But this is all just what if's- none of us have the spell, in book or scroll.
The wand would have been great to have ready for combat, but since her sleep spell does not have a save, unlike the wand, we are often better off with her using the sleep spell first. But that is specifically why V tried to give the sceptre to Loran, and then to Orum or Eonwe- so it could be used while she was casting the sleep spell. As it is, she is fine using it, but it would not be deployed for some rounds. And it is also important to note that we had no idea they were superior to us until after we were already in combat, so it is not like we would have assumed that the wand (and potion, etc.) should have been immediate actions. Old school games are resource management games- limited charges, doses, etc., not uses per day, so should be used when necessary, not as a first strike.
The scroll of monster summoning could possibly have turned the encounter around, but that was completely random. Centipedes or stirges would have been destroyed pretty much the same round as they were summoned. Lemures by monster description attack any non-devil near them, and I am not sure if that would override the 'serve caster' aspect of the spell. If so, wonderful. If not, we are in as big a danger as the dervishes would be. Troglodyte scent affects us just as much as them. And several of their rolls were enough to kill gnolls and troglodytes with a single strike. Giant toad would have been the ideal, but that was only a 1 in 6 chance. Given that, V was better off using sleep to guarantee the opposition was taken out than trusting the scroll would deliver results.
And while you are the DM and of course have the final say, and I completely respect that, I disagree that it was an evil act to kill the two dervishes outside. Self-preservation is not an inherently evil act. We did everything we could think of to avoid combat with anyone, and the dervishes wound up attacking us first. (Ironically, had we been evil, this scenario would have gone much better for us- we would have simply attacked them to start off with and that would have been far better for us than to allow them to surround us and start spellcasting.)
The Holy Laseda also made it clear that we are not people to them. 'You are not people. You are infidels' and we were also referred to as 'desert scum' by his followers. Despite the tonal shift of their comedy, there is no reason to believe that the two members of his group stationed outside who had the same protective task did not feel the same way or would not come for us, and they also know what we look like so we cannot profess to simply be travelers like we could if any of the others from inside try to find us.
And meta-wise, you intimated, at least as I understood it, that they would come to kill us in the ooc thread. 'There are two more guards outside the temple who might well be roused by the commotion.' I had said we would sneak away invisibly since they would probably check on the leader and unwedge the doors rather than try to attack us, but you responded 'Zealots are not reasonable people.'
Given all that, and given the condition we were in at the time, that was not an evil act- it was self-preservation to protect ourselves from members of a group that attacked us and that the DM told us were not reasonable people.
Attacking them from surprise/unaware was not honorable, but none of us are cavaliers.
Now, if the two had given any indication at all that they did not share the Lasada's beliefs inside, or were coerced into service or the like, then that would make sense. But as it is, no. And that is not even considering that they essentially told us they practiced bestiality, even if that was some time ago, so V is not exactly shedding any tears over them anyway.)
(For the record, I also do not particularly consider that the dervishes were evil either. They had their task that they believed in, we had ours, and they were just at odds. But again- they were the ones who attacked.)
Orum- if you were not for attacking the two outside, did you mean initially, or after we saw them together? She had mentioned that was her plan back in msg #357, and there had not been any objections at the time. But if she had known you objected, she would have let them be, against her better judgment. I really do not want to push anyone into things they would prefer not to do.
I am not sure going over a wall would matter, and am not sure about where else we could have scouted? The Lasada and most dervishes were inside the structure, and that is where the conflict grew hot. Or am I misunderstanding this?
Well, that was an essay. A poorly written and stream of thought one, but essay nonetheless.
TL/DR
Bottom line from what I see though is that the DM is confirming this is the adventure, so we go back in after resting, healing, and preparing combat spells.
Happy Thanksgiving all!
This message was last edited by the player at 03:04, Fri 24 Nov 2023.