Ten Questions about Gilly
Well, we're all a pretty dodgy lot from our brief descriptions, so no one stands out as the obvious paladin that the dying priest would have entrusted the religious icon to. Having said that, one of us is a foreigner (sorry, Deitrich), one of us is clearly a scoundrel (sorry, Heinrich), and one of us is a halfling (I can't hide it), so my best deduction would be that the old priest would have pressed the icon into the sweaty hands of Mein Herr Bauer, and he still has it tucked away in his rather the worse for wear leather jerkin.
Just my 2 cents. (Is there an equivalent Scottish idiom? Just my tuppence doesn't ring any bells.)